Fine Dining in Cooperstown, New York

Steak House Cafe

Whether you’re looking for romantic lakefront dining at Otsego Lake, family style menus, or trendy New York cafe's, Cooperstown offers a variety of delicious options. Best Western Inn & Suites at the Commons is walking distance or a short drive to many Cooperstown restaurants.

O’Hanlans American Steak House. Located next door to Best Western Inn & Suites at the Commons, O’Hanlans American Steak House serves mouthwatering grilled steak and seafood. O’Hanlans offers off–site catering services and accommodates groups up to 300 for special events in their banquet room. Daily, 4:00PM to 9:00PM. Telephone: (607) 544–1401.

The Bean Cafe. Located just footsteps from the Best Western, The Bean Cafe is open year round.  They have an extensive breakfast and lunch menu.  Telephone: (607) 544–9999.

The Blue Mingo Grill. Situated on Otsego Lake, The Blue Mingo Grill is open from mid–May through September. An extensive lunch and dinner menu features everything from crisp salads and grilled sandwiches to braised duck with red curry sauce and fresh Maine lobster. Seasonal hours of operations: Lunch, daily from 11:30AM to 2:30PM. Dinner, daily from 5:00PM to 10:00PM. Dinner reservations recommended. Telephone: (607) 547–7496.  [Top]

Nicoletta’s Italian Cafe. Nicoletta’s Italian Café, located on Main Street in downtown Cooperstown, boasts rave reviews from upstate New York locals and visitors. Enjoy Southern Italian cuisine prepared by chef/owner Phillip Andrews. Signature entrees include veal saltimbocca, lobster ravioli, and filet mignon served over fettuccini in gorgonzola cream sauce. Dinner: daily from 4:00PM. Reservations highly recommended. Telephone: (607) 547–7499.

TJ’s Place/The Home Plate. For country–style breakfast, juicy burgers, barbecue ribs, and homemade desserts, TJ’s Place/The Home Plate in downtown Cooperstown in the perfect choice. This family style restaurant is decorated floor to ceiling in baseball memorabilia, including autographed photos of legendary players. Full bar. Daily, 7:30AM to 8:00PM. Telephone: (607) 547–4040.

Hoffman Lane Bistro. Enjoy a summer afternoon dining alfresco at Hoffman Lane Bistro. This charming restaurant is located in downtown Cooperstown and serves such delectable dishes as pan–seared salmon, grilled pork loin, honey and herb roasted chicken, and crisp salads. Wine list and children’s menu available. Sunday – Thursday, 5:00PM to 9:00PM. Friday and Saturday, 5:00PM to 10:00PM. Telephone: (607) 547–7055.  [Top]